The Storied Life of A. J. Fikry: A Short Novel or An Inflated Novella

Storied Life of AJ FikryA.J. Fikry, the title character of Gabrielle Zevin’s slim novel, is a thirty-nine year-old, lonely bookseller at Island Books. He will only stock books which meet his high standards for literary content. As he explains to Amelia Loman, the new Knightly Press representative:

I do not like postmodernism, postapocalyptic settings, postmortem narrators, or magic realism. I rarely respond to supposedly clever formal devices, multiple fonts, pictures where they shouldn’t be—basically, gimmicks of any kind. I find literary fiction about the Holocaust or any other major world tragedy to be distasteful—nonfiction only, please. I do not like genre mashups à la the literary detective novel or the literary fantasy… I do not like children’s books, especially ones with orphans, and I prefer not to clutter my shelves with young adult. I do not like anything over four hundred pages or under one hundred fifty pages. I am repulsed by ghostwritten novels by reality television stars, celebrity picture books, sports memoirs, movie tie-in editions, novelty items, and—I imagine this goes without saying–vampires. [The list goes on and on]

With A.J.’s taste, it’s hard to believe he finds anything worthy enough to grace the shelves of the store he started with his wife, the more socially-inclined half who died in a car accident. How is his independent bookstore going to survive in the increasingly competitive bookselling world? As Amelia tells him, tearfully on her way out, “[with] this backward way of thinking, there won’t be an Island Books before too long.”

But A.J. isn’t in the right mindset to care. He’s barely hanging onto life after his wife’s death. He’s an eccentric man with a tragic past who happens to have a very big heart underneath his cold exterior.

I loved the first 50% of this book for its quirky, endearing characters and the sweet story, but I wish The Storied Life of A.J. Fikry had stopped there (at the end of the chapter named after Flannery O’Connor’s A Good Man Is Hard to Find). The rest of the novel felt rushed, as it sped through time and tied up loose ends by focusing on too many people and subplots, including one about the stolen copy of Edgar Allen Poe’s Tamerlane and a fraudulent memoir à la James Frey’s A Million Little Pieces.* The extra characters and storylines either needed more development to make them worthwhile, thus resulting in a novel longer than 273 pages, or they needed to be cut entirely, halving the book.**

The second half of the book took me forever to read, partly because my real-life was too distracting last week (with work deadlines and my twins’ camp show, which was lovely), and partly because it just felt superfluous to me (I wouldn’t have minded a few loose ends). Nevertheless, I’m glad I powered through it, and that I read this novel in the first place, which I probably never would’ve picked up had it not been for The Fellowship of the Worms read-along at Words for Worms (thanks, Katie!).***

A.J. Fikry’s “storied life” reminds us that there are many ways to form a family, including through blood, marriage, adoption, and even shared interests, like books. This novel made me think about the last time I set foot in a bookstore, which was a long time ago. In my area, the indie bookstores disappeared a decade or more ago, and the large chains are following suit. I am primarily an e-book reader now.

I love e-books for the freedom that comes with them—i.e., the ability to read a wide selection of books instantaneously and to carry around my entire library wherever I go—but, naturally, A.J. hates them. He believes they’re destroying his business, ruining literary culture, and enabling readers who have “bad taste” to “read crap.” He says:

Everyone thinks they have good taste, but most people do not have good taste. In fact, I’d argue that most people have terrible taste. When left to their own devices—literally their own devices—they read crap and they don’t know the difference.

Well, of course, a snobby (but still lovable) bookseller like A.J. would think readers need him to help them choose books because they can’t trust their own taste.

Personally, I don’t care what a person’s reading, as long as they’re reading something, but maybe A.J. has a point. Independent booksellers who understand the tastes of their community (often unlike the massive chain stores that just stock national bestsellers) can certainly help us separate the wheat from the chaff. Book blogs are important for recommending books–I rely on several of them–but they (we) can’t entirely replace professional booksellers, because most of us don’t have the time, resources, or incentive to tailor recommendations to individuals or to survey all of the new releases across a wide variety of genres. I do this as a hobby; it’s not my profession.

What I’d love to have in my neighborhood to complement the expertise at our local library is a co-op bookstore. I’d pay a membership fee to browse selected titles and receive recommendations from people dedicated to books that appeal to my community. I’d love to attend readings and author events in my neighborhood, and I’d love to have the ability to connect with real-life readers in addition to the “virtual” ones that I’m lucky enough to meet through this blog. It’s too late for me to go back to buying primarily paper books—though I do buy them occasionally—but I’d be happy to buy e-books through a local seller. It might be hard to compete with Amazon’s prices, but I’d pay more per e-book to support a business that is part of my community.****

*The charlatan responsible for the memoir defends herself by saying, “All the things in it are still emotionally true even if they aren’t literally so.” For my thoughts on consumer fraud in fiction (under U.S. law), see J.K. Rowling as “Robert Galbraith”: Is It Consumer Fraud? (I briefly mention A Million Little Pieces in this post, but its focus is on the fake military experience in the biography of Robert Galbraith).

**The advertising material online lists the book as being 273 pages long. I read the e-book, which doesn’t have page numbers.

***Have you read this novel? If so, please check out Katie’s Fellowship of the Worms to join the discussion on The Storied Life of A. J. Fikry.

****Not that I find Amazon particularly troubling. See What’s Troubling About Amazon?and Did Apple Leave Amazon’s Kindle “In The Dust”?



  1. I think AJ would be a person that would be hard to like. Too many dislikes makes him sound like a curmudgeon. Maybe he is right in many respects, but times change and not always for the better – as in the taste of individuals. I do miss the independent book seller. We had one in the city and now his store is long gone. What replaced it? A porn shop.

  2. Sounds really interesting! I still prefer paper to e-books, but I look forward to the day when more independent e-book publishers step up and start changing my mind about this. Right now I live in New York so I’m surrounded by used and independent bookstores. There’s even a co-op library like what you suggested called Mellow Pages that hosts readings almost every night.

    I still feel like publishers and writers need to keep innovating if we want to keep our industry alive. Perhaps e-books shouldn’t be viewed as the enemy, but rather as a powerful tool to get more people interested in an alternative kind of reading.

  3. I always buy ebooks now. I rarely glance at the supermarket racks of paperbacks, and that is unheard of if you know me. A couple days ago, boxes of books I’d temporarily stored up north finally came back to me, and I spent one evening unpacking and putting them on the shelves. In bed that night, I held a real book instead of the Kindle. It was quite nice. 🙂

  4. I have not yet read this one, but I would like to. Thank you for the heads up about the second half.

    I admit I do not often visit my local indie store either. Or even the Barnes and Noble in town. I used to visit every other week–and walk out the door with more books that was good for me.

  5. A.J. sounds like the kind of character I would hate to love, and love to hate! I love when authors really dive into little patterns in character’s behavior. It can completely make or break a reader’s attachment to the characters.

    This book sounds pretty good… would it be the type of book you could possibly only read the first 1/2 of + still enjoy? It sounds like things went downhill after mid-book.

  6. Ooh! I just got this book from the library yesterday, after spending awhile on the hold list. I’ve been looking forward to reading it. Hopefully the second half doesn’t drag too much for me.

    Also, I think IndieBound has a way to buy ebooks directly from independent bookstores, but I’m not sure how it works with Kindle.

  7. I sort of saw A.J. as being crotchety just for the sake of it. He doesn’t like much of anything at that moment because he is grieving.

    You make some great points about bookstores. I would love to spend some more time at the indie closest to me, but parking is a nightmare and it’s tough to find time to go without bringing two small kids in tow!

    1. Hi Lindsey! I completely understand how difficult it is to browse books with little ones in tow! We’d never leave the kids’ section. I think you’re right that much of AJ’s behavior is directly related to grieving. I doubt he was ever very good at social interaction, though. That was Nic’s role in the relationship.

  8. Ooooh this is such a great post! I hadn’t thought about it much, but I think you’re right about the book’s length. The beginning was done beautifully but the end was rushed. I think I’d have preferred it to be a bit longer in developing the end of the story than to have it lopped off, but once I get attached to a character, I’ll read through thousands of pages. I also like the sounds of your imaginary co-op bookstore.

  9. Love the premise of the book – if financial considerations were put aside wouldn’t we all like to run a bookshop and exclude stuff not to our taste? Here in Jersey we lost a wonderful old-fashioned second hand bookshop some years back when the owner died. I’m sure there are some still around elsewhere with the owners not having a clue what’s on the shelves.

  10. I love both Fikry characters: early and late book. The indie bookstore spunk was fun to read. And you are right, a bit too much tied together, but it was still enjoyable. I’ll go check out the Worms now. Thanks!

    1. I’m glad to hear that you loved Fikry throughout the book. The second half was a struggle for me, but I still think the novel was worth reading. Thanks for stopping by!

  11. I’ve never thought of asking someone who works in a bookstore to recommend a book for me…that would involve human interaction! Usually I read about books and then go find them. It’s not like I spend a lot of time without a book wondering what to read next.
    The Storied Life of A.J. Fikry was recommended to me by someone I met at Walker Percy weekend last month. I’m waiting for it at the library.

    1. I hope you enjoy it! I really loved the first 50%. The rest isn’t bad, but it just didn’t keep my attention the way the first half did.

      Asking a bookseller for a recommendation would involve human interaction, but booksellers can recommend books to us without it. If they understand their customers, they select and showcase books that are likely to appeal to them. It wouldn’t be an individualized recommendation, but it can still work. I learn about new books from blogs, but there are some books (such as ones tied to my location through the author or the setting) that I’m unlikely to find on any of the blogs I read and more likely to find at my closest indie bookstore (which isn’t that close to me, unfortunately).

      Thanks for stopping by!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s